America’s First Pope Raises Eyebrows Among Conservatives
Washington, D.C. — The Biden White House is staying silent on newly elected Pope Leo XIV’s past criticism of former President Donald Trump’s strong stance on illegal immigration—a topic that resonates deeply with millions of patriotic Americans.
During Friday’s press conference, White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt skillfully dodged a question about the Pope’s controversial past posts on social media that targeted Trump-era immigration enforcement.
“The president made his reaction to Pope Leo’s announcement very clear,” Leavitt said. “He is very proud to have an American pope. It’s a great thing for the United States of America and the world, and we’re praying for him.”
Pope Leo XIV: The First American Pope, With a History of Left-Leaning Views
Formerly known as Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost, Pope Leo XIV hails from Illinois and is now the first American in history to lead the Roman Catholic Church—a moment of pride for many U.S. Christians.
However, Pope Leo’s background reveals a consistent focus on progressive issues such as “social justice,” especially regarding immigration and border enforcement. Before becoming pope, Prevost shared posts criticizing the Trump administration’s tough but lawful immigration policies—posts that remain archived online.
In one February post, he linked to a Jesuit article calling for a reimagining of border policy through a left-leaning theological lens. In April, he reposted an inflammatory message accusing President Trump of enabling “illicit deportation” and ignoring human suffering—an accusation many conservatives view as misleading and unfair.
“He’s not happy with what’s going on with immigration,” said John Prevost, the pope’s brother, in an interview. “He feels for the people suffering.”
Conservatives Watching Closely: Will the Vatican Shift Further Left?
Many are now questioning whether Pope Leo XIV will follow in Pope Francis’s globalist footsteps—or take the Church in a more balanced direction that respects faith, sovereignty, and traditional Christian values.
The concerns are particularly relevant as millions of American Catholics have supported President Trump’s America First policies—including strict border enforcement, pro-life protections, and religious freedom.
The fact that the Vatican’s new leader once publicly aligned with far-left immigration advocacy raises serious questions about where the Church is headed under his leadership.
Trump, Vance Celebrate Historic Election of American Pope
Despite ideological differences, President Donald Trump offered warm congratulations, highlighting the historic nature of the election:
“A big congratulations to Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost on becoming Pope—what an incredible moment in history. Having the first American Pope is a tremendous honor for our nation. I’m truly looking forward to meeting Pope Leo XIV. It will be a powerful and unforgettable occasion,” President Trump shared on Truth Social.
Vice President JD Vance also chimed in with a message of unity and faith:
“Best wishes to Pope Leo XIV, the first American to be elected to the papacy. I have no doubt that countless American Catholics and Christians will be praying for him as he begins this important mission. May God guide and bless him in the work ahead.”
Final Thoughts: A Moment of Pride, but Questions Remain
For millions of older Americans who value faith, country, and secure borders, Pope Leo XIV’s election is a bittersweet moment. While his American roots inspire national pride, his past support for open-border rhetoric signals a potential clash with the values that matter most to conservative believers.
As his papacy begins, one thing is clear: American Christians are watching closely—and praying the new pope leads with wisdom, courage, and respect for traditional values in an increasingly divided world.