An Historic Catholic Moment Overshadowed by Old Political Grudges
While millions of faithful Americans celebrated the election of Pope Leo XIV, the first-ever American to lead the Catholic Church, former Wyoming Representative Liz Cheney used the moment to reignite her feud with President Donald J. Trump.
In a post on X (formerly Twitter), Cheney praised the pope—but in the same breath, issued what many viewed as a pointed insult toward Trump, describing an unnamed “American man” marked by “cruelty, corruption, and shame.”
Cheney’s History of Opposition to Trump
Although Cheney didn’t mention Trump by name, her meaning was clear. After years of siding with Democrats and the mainstream media, Cheney’s attacks have become a recurring feature of her public persona:
- She was one of ten House Republicans who voted to impeach President Trump after January 6, 2021.
- She served on the partisan January 6 Committee, alongside Democrats, to investigate Trump and his supporters.
- She endorsed Kamala Harris for president in 2024, completely abandoning the Republican base.
This shift has alienated Cheney from most conservatives, who once respected her father, Vice President Dick Cheney, as a pillar of Republican leadership.
Trump’s Gracious Response to the New Pope
While Cheney was launching barbs, President Trump responded to the historic moment with dignity and national pride. On Truth Social, he wrote:
“Congratulations to Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost, who was just named Pope. It is such an honor to realize that he is the first American Pope. What excitement, and what a Great Honor for our Country.”
Trump’s message was focused on faith, unity, and national pride—hallmarks of his enduring appeal to traditional, patriotic Americans.
A Political Agenda Behind Cheney’s Praise
Cheney’s message read in part:
“In an era that looked as if it might be defined by an American man of depraved cruelty… what a magnificent thing the Catholic Church has done.”
Many saw the comment as an unnecessary politicization of a sacred moment. Instead of celebrating Pope Leo XIV’s historic rise, Cheney used the opportunity to reopen wounds and divide Americans.
Pope Leo XIV’s Controversial Past Posts
Before his elevation, Cardinal Prevost (now Pope Leo XIV) ran a social media account where he occasionally reposted content critical of the Trump administration, particularly on immigration and foreign policy. For example:
- In April, he reshared criticism of Trump’s meeting with El Salvador’s president.
- In February, he reposted an article pushing back on Vice President JD Vance’s biblical views on patriotism.
While many Catholics support the new pope, some are raising concerns about his past political leanings.
Biden’s Last-Minute Pardons of Cheney and Allies
Before leaving office, President Joe Biden issued pardons for Cheney and the other January 6 Committee members. Trump had previously stated:
“Honestly, they should go to jail.”
Cheney responded to the pardon with a self-righteous tone, saying:
“We have been pardoned today not for breaking the law but for upholding it.”
A Divided GOP, A United Faith
Even as the Republican Party rallies around President Trump and Vice President JD Vance, Cheney continues her campaign of opposition. At a recent event in Alaska, she hinted at a future political run.
But for many conservatives, the contrast is clear:
- Trump leads with strength and patriotism.
- Cheney clings to division and Democrat talking points.
In an age where faith, freedom, and American values matter more than ever, Liz Cheney’s message feels increasingly out of touch.